Cost & Pricing•9 min read

CNC Machining Cost Per Part: The Eight Lines That Explain a 40% Quote Gap

Two suppliers quote the same drawing and the numbers are 40% apart. Neither is lying and neither is necessarily cheaper. The gap sits in eight lines that almost no quotation shows you: machine time, setup, tolerance, yield, tooling, finishing, inspection, and the commercial assumptions underneath them. This article opens the ledger with our own rates — 160 CNY an hour on a three-axis machine, 400 on a five-axis — and shows which line actually moves the price.

Two quotes, one drawing: where the difference actually sits

A buyer sends the same STEP file to three suppliers. The quotes come back at 18, 22 and 26 CNY per part. The instinct is to ask the highest one why they are expensive, and to assume the lowest one is the honest one.

That instinct is usually wrong. The three quotes describe three different production plans. One supplier assumed two setups, another four. One priced in a 3% scrap allowance, another 30%. One quoted an inspection method that cannot actually verify the tolerance on the drawing.

Here is the ledger we use internally. Every quote is these eight lines, whether or not the supplier shows them:

# Line What it covers Where the gap hides
1 Material Bar or plate stock, plus the allowance you cut away Stock size chosen, not the finished size
2 Machine time Cutting time at the machine’s hourly rate Feed and speed strategy, and how much air-cutting
3 Setup Fixturing and zeroing, per operation How many setups the geometry forces
4 Tolerance The machine that can hold it, and the inspection that proves it Whether the tolerance is priced or hoped for
5 Yield Scrap and rework, as a multiplier on everything above Almost never stated
6 Tooling Inserts, drills, taps, and how long they last Tool life assumptions
7 Finishing Anodising, plating, passivation, deburring Whether finishing is in-house or subcontracted
8 Commercial Currency, payment terms, freight, MOQ Exchange rate and payment risk

Lines 1 and 2 are the ones buyers negotiate. Lines 3, 4 and 5 are the ones that actually move the number.

Lines 1–2: machine time, at rates you can check

Our shop runs three-axis machining centres at 160 CNY per hour and five-axis machines at 400 CNY per hour. At roughly 7.2 CNY to the dollar, that is about $22 and $55 an hour.

Converted to the only unit that matters for a quote:

160 CNY/h ÷ 60 = 2.67 CNY per minute   (three-axis)
400 CNY/h ÷ 60 = 6.67 CNY per minute   (five-axis)

A five-axis machine therefore costs 2.5 times as much per minute as a three-axis machine. That is the number buyers see, and it is the number they argue about. It is also the least interesting number in the ledger, because a five-axis machine can remove setups — and setups are what the next line is about.

When five-axis is cheaper per part, and when it is 2.5× dearer

Take a bracket, 120 × 80 × 25 mm in 6061 aluminium, that needs work on four faces.

  • Three-axis route: 45 minutes of cutting plus a 15-minute setup, 60 minutes total. At 160 CNY/h that is 160 CNY.
  • Five-axis route: 30 minutes of cutting plus one 15-minute setup, 45 minutes total — and what an extra axis actually buys is fewer setups, not a faster cut. At 400 CNY/h that is 300 CNY.

On this part the five-axis machine is nearly twice as expensive, because the geometry only needs two setups anyway. Change the part — a housing with ports on five faces and a true position callout between them — and the three-axis route needs four setups, four chances to stack positional error, and roughly twice the handling time. The five-axis route then wins, not because it cuts faster (it does not), but because it holds the part once.

The rule we use: count the setups the geometry forces. If that number is above three, price the five-axis route. If it is one or two, do not.

Line 3: setup, amortised over the batch

A conventional setup — fixture on the table, dial in, touch off tools, prove the first article — takes about 15 minutes in our shop for a repeat part.

At the three-axis rate that is 40 CNY per setup. At the five-axis rate it is 100 CNY. What matters is not the number but where it lands:

Batch Setup per part, three-axis Setup per part, five-axis
1 40.00 CNY 100.00 CNY
10 4.00 CNY 10.00 CNY
100 0.40 CNY 1.00 CNY
1,000 0.04 CNY 0.10 CNY

This is the entire explanation for why ten pieces cost more than a hundred. It is not that the machine is slower on small batches; it is that a fixed cost has fewer parts to spread across.

It also explains a common quote gap. A supplier who plans two setups and a supplier who plans four are not disagreeing about the hourly rate — they are disagreeing about how the part will be held. That is a technical question, and it has a right answer.

Line 4: tolerance, and what 0.005 mm actually changes

Our standard tolerance is 0.005 mm. It is not a default we apply to everything; it is what our machines and inspection can hold on a normal part without heroics.

What that tolerance changes is not one line but three:

  1. The machine. A 0.005 mm callout on a positioned feature usually means a machine with thermal compensation and a probe, which is the five-axis rate or a high-end three-axis with the right options.
  2. The inspection. You cannot verify 0.005 mm with a caliper. It needs a CMM, and a CMM check on a small batch can add a fixed cost comparable to the machining itself.
  3. The scrap rate while the process is proven. The first parts off a new setup are the ones that get scrapped. On a tight tolerance that cost is concentrated at the start of the run.

A supplier who quotes 0.005 mm without a CMM is not pricing the tolerance. They are pricing the hope that nobody measures it. That is one of the most common reasons a low quote becomes an argument three weeks later.

Line 5: yield — 70% versus 98% is 29% of the price

This is the line we care about most, and the one almost never shown.

Our industry’s normal first-pass yield on a mixed job shop is around 70%. Ours runs at 98% on repeat work, because we control the process inputs rather than inspecting the failures out.

The arithmetic is simple and it dominates everything else:

To ship 1 good part at 70% yield:  1 ÷ 0.70 = 1.43 parts must be started
To ship 1 good part at 98% yield:  1 ÷ 0.98 = 1.02 parts must be started

Cost ratio:  1.43 ÷ 1.02 = 1.40

A 70% yield shop spends 40% more to produce the same shippable part. Turn it around: moving from 70% to 98% cuts the effective cost per good part by 29%.

Put the example bracket through it:

Route Machine cost At 70% yield At 98% yield
Three-axis, 60 min 160 CNY 229 CNY 163 CNY
Five-axis, 45 min 300 CNY 429 CNY 306 CNY

The three-axis route at 98% yield (163 CNY) is 46% cheaper than the five-axis route at 98% yield (306 CNY) on this part. The five-axis machine only earns its rate when the geometry demands it — which is line 3 again, not line 5.

Why yield is the line suppliers leave out

Because it is the one number that exposes the shop. A supplier can quote a competitive hourly rate and lose money on scrap; the customer never sees it until delivery slips. Asking “what first-pass yield did you price in?” is the single most useful question a buyer can ask, and very few buyers ask it.

Lines 6–8: tooling, finishing, inspection

Tooling is small in absolute terms and large in variance. An insert that lasts 40 parts and one that lasts 15 change the per-part cost by more than the hourly rate does on a long run.

Insert life is decided by five factors, and they all push the same way — harder conditions, shorter life:

  1. Cutting speed (Vc). Higher speed, shorter life. This is the strongest of the five.
  2. Feed rate (f). Higher feed, shorter life.
  3. Depth of cut (ap). Deeper cut, shorter life.
  4. Workpiece material. The harder the material, the shorter the life — this is the factor buyers most often ignore when they ask why the same part in 304 costs more than in 6061.
  5. Coolant. Dry cutting gives the shortest life of all; flood or through-tool coolant is what makes a long run economic.

Finishing and inspection are the lines where suppliers differ most in scope rather than in rate. Anodising, passivation, deburring and CMM reports are frequently subcontracted, which adds a margin and a lead time. A quote that omits finishing is not cheaper — it is a different scope.

The table to send your supplier

If you want comparable quotes, send the same six questions with the drawing. Two suppliers answering the same six questions are comparable; three suppliers answering none are three guesses.

Six questions a supplier must be able to answer:

  1. How many setups does this part need, and where are they?
  2. What first-pass yield did you price in?
  3. Which machine, and at what hourly rate?
  4. How will you verify the tightest tolerance, and is the inspection in the price?
  5. What is included in finishing — in-house or subcontracted?
  6. What is your scrap and rework policy if parts fail at your end?

Three questions they can legitimately refuse:

  1. Their internal margin structure.
  2. Their customer list.
  3. Their sub-tier supplier names.

Everything else in this article is arithmetic. None of it requires you to trust us.

What this article cannot do

We do not have your drawing. Nothing here is a quotation, and none of the numbers should be used as a budget figure for a specific part — the machine time of your part decides the answer, and until someone looks at the geometry that number does not exist.

What the article can do is give you the eight lines, our rates, and the six questions. If a supplier cannot answer them, you have learned something more useful than a lower price. When you do have a drawing in hand, send it to us and we will quote it against these same eight lines.


Rates quoted are our own shop rates for 2026, in CNY, at approximately 7.2 CNY to the USD. They are published so that buyers can check our arithmetic rather than take our word for it.

Frequently asked

Is a five-axis machine always more expensive per part?
No. It is more expensive per hour — 400 CNY against 160 in our shop — but it can remove setups. On a part that would need four setups on a three-axis machine, the five-axis machine can win. On a part that needs one setup either way, the five-axis machine is 2.5 times the hourly cost for no gain. The question is always how many setups the geometry forces, not which machine is newer.
Why is my quote 40% higher than another supplier's for the same drawing?
Almost always one of three things. They assumed a different number of setups; they priced in a different scrap rate; or one of them quoted a tolerance they cannot actually hold and will discover it during production. Ask each supplier for their assumed setups, their first-pass yield and their inspection method. The supplier who can give you all three is usually the one whose number will hold.
Does a 0.005 mm tolerance triple the price?
It does not triple it on its own, but it changes three things at once: the machine that can hold it, the inspection that can prove it, and the scrap rate while you learn to hold it. In our experience the tolerance line is the most common reason two quotes diverge on the same drawing, because one supplier is pricing the tolerance and the other is pricing what they hope will happen.
How much does setup add at 100 pieces?
At a 15-minute setup and our three-axis rate of 160 CNY/h, one setup costs 40 CNY. At 100 pieces that is 0.40 CNY per part — negligible. At 10 pieces it is 4 CNY, and at one piece it is the whole 40. This is why small batches are expensive: not because the machining is slower, but because the setup has nowhere to hide.
Can I get a lower price without changing the drawing?
Sometimes, but not by negotiating the hourly rate. The two levers that do not touch the drawing are yield and setup count: a supplier running 98% first-pass yield is 29% cheaper per good part than one running 70%, and every setup removed takes both time and positional error out of the part. Ask what the yield is before asking for a discount.

Have a part this article describes?

Send the drawing, the material callout and the quantity. You get DFM feedback and a price within 24 hours, and orders start at 50 pieces per style and material.

More in Cost & Pricing

All articles →